Copy Desk

How to give feedback on AI copy so you only say it once

The draft is close. One line is off, the rhythm is wrong, and you know exactly what it should say. You send the fix. The new draft comes back and the line is better, but two sentences you had already approved are gone, and a third has moved to a different paragraph. Now you are reading the whole thing again.

I have been there. One usable piece from a general AI chat took me about ten rounds of feedback. Each round I was rereading everything, because each round was a new draft.

Why every round becomes a full reread

A change request is read as a request to write again. You say "fix line three". The tool hears "here is new information, produce a draft". So it produces a draft. Every round is a fresh start, and every round has to be read in full to find what moved.

So make the request one that cannot be read as a rewrite.

Kind one: a change

Name the line. Say the change.

"The second sentence in the opening paragraph: change 'streamline' to 'cut.' Keep everything else word for word."

That is a complete feedback note. It leaves no room for a rewrite.

Kind two: a question

Ask it. Say you want an answer with the piece left as it is.

"Does the guarantee belong in the opening paragraph or after the price? Answer the question. Leave the piece as it is."

You get the answer. You decide. You then give a kind-one note if you want to move something.

Kind three: your own version

Sometimes you have already written the line. Paste it in. Tell the tool to check only for spelling, grammar and any sentence too long to say aloud, and to leave the rest exactly as it is.

This is the fastest kind of feedback: a proofread of your own words.

The cut

When a piece is too long, ask for whole sentences to go, the weakest first. Name how many you want removed.

Asking for every sentence to be a little shorter spreads the change across the whole piece, and you are back to rereading everything. One sentence cut is one sentence gone. You read the list of what was cut, you check the two sentences around the gap, and you are done.

What I measured

I built Copy Desk to work this way, and I timed it.

One line changed: 8 seconds. Every other sentence was word for word. The tool returned a list of what changed.

A request to shorten: 8 seconds.

A question answered: 5 seconds. The piece was untouched.

The list of what changed is what saves the reread. You read the list and the lines around each change.

Checklist for feedback that works the first time

  1. Name the line you are changing, by its position or its first three words.
  2. Say the change in one sentence.
  3. If you are cutting, name how many sentences go and say to remove the weakest ones first.
  4. If you are asking a question, say you want the piece left as it is.
  5. If you have your own version, paste it and say to touch only spelling, grammar and length.
  6. When the draft comes back, read only the list of what changed, then check the lines around each change.

That is the whole method. Name the line. Say the change. Read only the list.

Copy Desk

Copy Desk is a chat tool that writes marketing copy from your own facts. You brief it the way you would brief a writer. It hands back one finished piece. Feedback changes the line you name, keeps every other sentence word for word and lists what changed.

Create my account